~ 56 ~

[wandthief]

Now Hix is gone do the rest of you want a notorious dark wizard roaming around unwatched and unchecked? Any volunteers to amuse me by attempting to be my temporary warden?

Admiral, I want my powers returned to me as they were when I arrived. That's only fair.


[Private to Arthas and Frostmourne]

Did you frighten Hix that much that he had to flee?

Comments

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

When I first came here, I couldn't have answered that.

Now? Morally ambiguous but with a strong and healthy inclination not to murder people. Or throw them over the side.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

But you have murdered people?

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

You know the answer to that. You did read my story.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

It did not say every little thing you did, as it did not say everything that I did.

It wasn't inside of your mind. It didn't say what you enjoyed or didn't enjoy of what you did.

So I'd like to hear the truth from you.

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

You asked if I murdered people, not whether I enjoyed it.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

Now I'm asking both.

Although I'm not surprised about you evading giving me a direct answer.

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

If you're not surprised, then I imagine you think you already have an answer.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

No, which is why I am asking.

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

I have never enjoyed murder.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

Would you call what you did to Dumbledore murder?

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

Yes.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

Hm.

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

You don't?

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

It was something he felt had to be done, was it not?

Without much thought for yourself. As you said, you don't enjoy murder. He always did have a selfish streak.

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

Does it make it any less reprehensible that I had his permission?

Assisted suicide is still murder.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

It wasn't quite that either though.

Grand plans. Manipulations. He really didn't change very much.

I could be angry at you for what you did, you realise, but I know all too well what he could be like.

Filtered away from Neville

[subtlescience]

You don't know what you're talking about.

Filtered away from Neville

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

Oh?

DUMDEDUM STILL FILTERED FROM NEVILLE.

[subtlescience]

You presume to know me and my relationship with him based on what could amount to little vignettes of conversations, taken from a book written from the viewpoint of a child.

You think this absolution you've given me is any comfort for the fact that I murdered him? He was a manipulative bastard, so it's all right? Yes, I'll sleep better nights knowing I have Gellert Grindelwald's seal of approval.

FILTERED FROM NEVILLE

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

I'm not approving of your actions. I just understand he had a master plan, as did I. His involved some disagreeable things and he asked a great deal of you, if those fictionalised accounts are in any way accurate.

I know as much about your true relationship with him as you do of my relationship with him. Which is to say: very little.

Which is why I prefer it this way, speaking to you directly.

No-Nevilles Club

[subtlescience]

His plan may have involved some disagreeable things, but the alternative was much less preferable.

Preserving Neville's 4th wall

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

By that I presume you mean his plans with myself.

Or the way your own path was heading.

To be honest I don't see what any of you could have seen in Voldemort. Oh, as a youth I'm sure he was charming but later? Smart to turn against him, whatever your reason.

Pfft. WE JUST DON'T LIKE YOU NEVILLE. (...Okay, I lie.) Filtered from Nev.

[subtlescience]

Things that seem like good ideas at first quickly lose their shine when people start dying - and then loyalty becomes motivated by fear.

XD Filtered from Nev.

[wandthief.livejournal.com]

So you agree that he was an egotistical fool?

I saw him once in person and all he seemed to be was... flustered. It was amusing, really.

Filtered from Nev. because his feet smell like herbs.

[subtlescience]

He was.

I suspect he was flustered because he expected you to be dead.